Archbishop Justin Welby Must Resign Now for Shielding a Serial Abuser of Boys and Young Men

The recent findings from an independent investigation into John Smyth, a notorious serial sexual abuser, have sent shockwaves through the United Kingdom. This scandal has escalated to the point where it may threaten the position of Justin Welby, the Archbishop of Canterbury and head of the Church of England. The pressure is mounting for Welby to step down after failing to report Smyth’s abuses to law enforcement when he first learned about them.

Smyth was a volunteer at Christian summer camps and has been accused of committing horrific acts against approximately 30 boys and young men in the UK, as well as 85 more in Africa over several decades. According to an article by the Associated Press, members of the General Synod—the national assembly of the church—are circulating a petition demanding Welby’s resignation. As of Monday morning London time, this petition had already gathered more than 1,800 signatures on Change.org.

Bishop Helen-Ann Hartley from Newcastle has publicly declared that Welby’s position is now “untenable.” Calls for his resignation intensified following the release of the Makin Review last Thursday, which detailed Smyth’s extensive history of sexual, psychological, and physical abuse. Notably, Welby did not take action to inform authorities about Smyth when he became Archbishop in 2013.

In response to these allegations, Welby admitted that he did not pursue them with enough urgency but has firmly stated that he will not resign. His office released a statement expressing his horror at the extent of Smyth’s abuse. It emphasized that he had no prior knowledge or suspicion regarding these allegations before being informed in 2013 and that he does not intend to resign. The statement also mentioned his hope that the Makin Review would contribute positively toward making the church safer both locally and globally.

However, this issue goes beyond just one man’s failure; it reveals a deeper culture within the Church of England itself. The cover-up surrounding Smyth’s actions began long before Welby’s tenure—dating back to 1982—when there was an active effort to conceal these crimes from coming into public view. After moving to Africa, Smyth continued his abusive behavior until his death in 2018.

The truth about Smyth’s actions only came into public light due to a Channel 4 investigation in 2017. This prompted Hampshire Police to launch their own inquiry into him. Tragically, police were preparing to question Smyth at the time of his passing and had even been working on extradition plans.

The Makin Review highlighted how crucial it would have been if authorities had been alerted back in 2013; doing so might have prevented further abuse and potentially led to criminal charges against Smyth. The review concluded that “in effect, three and a half years was lost,” during which time additional victims could have been saved from suffering under Smyth’s predatory behavior.

This situation raises significant questions about accountability within religious institutions and whether leaders are truly prioritizing safety over reputation. As this story unfolds and public outrage grows louder, it remains clear that many are demanding justice—not just for past victims but also for future protection against such heinous acts.

What are your thoughts on this unfolding crisis? Share your opinions in the comment section below!

More Reading

Post navigation