The Biden-Harris administration is taking a strong stance against landlords who utilize criminal background checks when screening potential renters. This move aligns with an Obama-era housing rule that aims to prevent discrimination against individuals with criminal records. According to the Fair Housing Act, discrimination in housing based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or disability is already prohibited. However, in 2016, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) under President Obama expanded this definition to include individuals with criminal histories as a protected class.
Recently, federal prosecutors filed a lawsuit against the owners and managers of Suburban Heights Apartments located in Kinloch, Missouri. They argue that these landlords’ use of criminal background checks discriminates against Black individuals due to significant racial disparities in incarceration rates. The property itself markets itself as a “student village,” catering primarily to young renters from nearby universities. The management implemented these background checks under the belief that they would create a safer living environment for their tenants.
Despite these intentions, the Department of Justice (DOJ) has accused them of racial discrimination. The lawsuit seeks not only monetary damages but also civil penalties aimed at protecting public interests and preventing future discriminatory practices by landlords. The DOJ highlighted well-documented statistical disparities between Black and White incarceration rates in its legal argument.
The DOJ’s filing states that data shows Black individuals are significantly more likely than their White counterparts to have convictions that would be flagged by Suburban Heights’ Criminal History Ban. This trend is evident across the nation but is even more pronounced in areas like St. Louis City and St. Louis County. In fact, statistics indicate that Black individuals are at least four times more likely than White individuals to face incarceration throughout their lives.
Assistant Attorney General Kristen Clarke from the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division emphasized the seriousness of this issue by stating that rental property owners who impose bans on tenants with criminal histories may be violating the Fair Housing Act. She further explained how policies that reinforce racial discrimination can have devastating effects on communities of color.
Clarke made it clear: “This lawsuit should send a clear message to housing providers that certain criminal history bans on people seeking to put a roof over their heads are not just unfair but unlawful.” She affirmed the DOJ’s commitment to enforcing protections under the Fair Housing Act to combat all forms of housing discrimination based on race and color.
