On September 5, 2024, the Washington State Republican Party (WAGOP) and their attorney Joel Ard filed a lawsuit asserting that ballots “cured” by King County using the OmniBallot system appear to be invalid. This legal action follows a hand recount for second place in the August 6, 2024, WA State Primary Election for Commissioner of Public Lands. Voters should be grateful for the WAGOP’s efforts to ensure the integrity of our elections.
Washington is an all mail-in state. When a voter forgets to sign the ballot envelope or when the signature doesn’t match the one on record, “ballot curing” is necessary. This process involves informing the voter to correct their signature so their vote can be counted, as per WAC 434-261-053.
The lawsuit claims King County used an online tool that helped voters fix problems with their ballots, potentially affecting the outcome of the primary race for Public Lands Commissioner. Additionally, it alleges that King County Elections Director Julie Wise did not ensure adequate privacy and security protections for voter information transmitted over the app, which is operated by a private company.
According to the WAGOP, Republican Sue Kuehl Pederson would have defeated Democrat Dave Upthegrove if the app hadn’t been used. The party seeks to invalidate votes “cured” through this app.
King County Elections controls 17 of the State’s 49 Legislative Districts and contracted with Democracy Live, a leftist third-party corporation. Democracy Live operates the OmniBallot voting system, which utilized an online/mobile phone web app ballot curing program for the Primary Election.
The complaint states that King County counted 2,092 ballot signature affidavits illegally “cured” via Democracy Live’s OmniBallot system, violating RCW 29A.60.164(4). Without these votes, Upthegrove would have had virtually no chance of finishing ahead of Pederson for second place in the race.
After the statewide recount was officially certified on September 4, 2024, results changed slightly but still showed Republican Jaime Herrera Beutler and Democrat Dave Upthegrove as the top two candidates for the November general election. The recount indicated a 49-vote margin separating Upthegrove from Pederson. Before the recount, this margin stood at 51 votes out of over 1.9 million counted. After consolidating amended results from each of the 39 individual county canvassing boards, Upthegrove gained four votes and Pederson gained six.
During the manual recount, “overvotes,” “undervotes,” and “write-in” votes were identified, leading to minor changes in overall vote totals for the seven candidates across most WA State counties.
Democracy Live’s OmniBallot platform provides web-based services for blank ballot delivery, ballot marking, and online voting. However, there have been concerns about its security and certification status. A June 2021 report highlighted misleading claims by Democracy Live regarding federal certification of its systems. Despite assertions in a November 2019 press release, OmniBallot has never been granted EAC certification.
Security experts widely agree that any online transmission of voted ballots cannot be secured. Reports indicate that while OmniBallot can mark ballots printed and returned by mail, it sends voters’ identities and ballot choices to Democracy Live—an unnecessary risk jeopardizing voter privacy and secret ballots.
The web app relies on third parties like Amazon, Google, and Cloudflare to function. This reliance creates potential points of compromise within the election system. Furthermore, Democracy Live can receive sensitive personal information such as voter ID, ballot selections, signature selections, and even browser fingerprints—data that could be exploited for malicious purposes.
On April 9, 2020, more than 60 scientists and election experts signed a letter urging state officials not to allow internet voting systems due to well-established risks. Given these risks, it’s astonishing that such an insecure web app susceptible to manipulation and hacking would be used for any type of voting.
Bill Bruch is a prominent figure in WA State GOP circles: Election Integrity Chairman, WSRP Executive Board Member, four-term Skagit County GOP Chairman, citizen journalist, blogger, business owner, “2021 Citizen Activist of the Year,” former council member, and RNC National Convention Delegate in both 2016 and 2024.
What are your thoughts on this situation? Share your comments below!
