Judge Rules Against ADL’s Delay Tactic in Defamation Suit
The Honorable Reed O’Connor, Judge of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, Fort Worth Division, has ruled that the Anti-Defamation League’s (ADL) move to delay disabled Navy veteran John Sabal’s defamation suit has failed. With a trial date set for July 16, 2025, the case moves forward despite several attempts by the ADL to stop it.
Sabal, known for organizing patriotic festivals without any arrest history, claims that the ADL defamed him by listing his name in its Center on Extremism’s “Glossary of Extremism and Hate.” His name appears among 294 others, including infamous figures such as Osama bin Laden and Timothy McVeigh. The Glossary even reminds us that it includes “an al Qaeda member and the mastermind of the 9/11 terror attack.” This inclusion forms the basis of Sabal’s claim that the ADL portrays him as a “dangerous, extremist threat, and even a criminal.”
Judge O’Connor’s four-page ruling dismissed the ADL’s request for a mid-suit appeal, citing established case law. He stressed that “the mere fact that a disgruntled litigant intends to inevitably appeal does not create an exceptional case warranting a mid-suit appeal, and the law depended on by the ADL in its motion is ‘not a vehicle to question the correctness of a district court’s ruling or to obtain a second, more favorable opinion.’” This decision marks the third effort by the ADL’s defense team to delay the proceedings, with all previous attempts having been unsuccessful.
According to Warren V. Norred of NORRED LAW, “The ADL’s latest effort to delay John Sabal’s defamation suit has failed, as the court denied the ADL’s attempt for a mid-suit appeal and stay of proceedings based on a claim that Sabal is a public figure. In keeping with fine federal court tradition, this case will still be heard as scheduled in July.” Discovery has already concluded after a failed summary judgment effort by the ADL, and NORRED LAW stepped in following the unsuccessful motion to dismiss.
Judge O’Connor’s order carefully reviewed Sabal’s complaint, dismissing claims of injurious falsehood while upholding his defamation claim linked to the Glossary and the report “Hate in the Lone Star State.”
Readers, please share your thoughts and comment in the comment section below.
