Outrage Erupts: NYC Bar Owner Alleges Ex-Police Commish Caban’s Brother Engaged in Shocking Extortion Scheme, Prompting Police Investigation

In a stunning twist, Shamel Kelly, a Manhattan bar owner, has accused James Caban—brother of former NYPD Commissioner Edward Caban—of attempting to extort him for money in exchange for business favors. This accusation comes amid a broader federal investigation into the NYPD’s nightlife unit. Federal agents have issued subpoenas and are scrutinizing the phones of NYPD lieutenants responsible for handling bar-related complaints. These lieutenants are part of a special operations unit that addresses quality-of-life issues across precincts via 311 hotline calls. Edward Caban, who resigned as commissioner last Friday, has yet to comment on the allegations involving his brother.

According to The New York Post, sources reveal that lieutenants were allegedly instructed to go easy on bars that were clients of James Caban. They were reportedly told, “Do not do enforcement, just mediate.” This leniency extended to noise complaints, crowd disturbances, and even public indecency—all behaviors that disrupt neighborhoods. A Brooklyn bar owner also told NBC New York that James Caban tried to extort him last summer.

Shamel Kelly, owner of Juice & Moore on Mermaid Avenue in Coney Island, recounted his experience to NBC New York. He said he went to City Hall seeking relief from heavy police presence at his establishment. A mayoral staffer then introduced him to James Caban. Kelly’s bar had been plagued by numerous noise complaints according to records. He claimed that James Caban offered to resolve his issues with the police for a payment of $2,500.

“He said that he would mediate my issues with the NYPD,” Kelly told the station. “He could bring them to me, have a meeting, resolve our issues is what he specifically said he could do,” Kelly alleged. “After he said I had to pay him for it, I felt like it was him trying to extort me.”

Kelly refused the alleged $2,500 offer and eventually closed his bar. In the aftermath, the mayor’s office fired staffer Ray Martin on Wednesday over his alleged involvement in the scheme.

Thomas Donlon, a retired FBI official, stepped in as interim police commissioner on Friday. Edward Caban made history in 2023 as the NYPD’s first Hispanic commissioner and had pledged to crack down on crime during his tenure. Under his leadership, major crimes—including homicides—saw a notable decline.

What do you think about these allegations against James Caban? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Source: [The Gateway Pundit](https://thegatewaypundit.com/)

More Reading

Post navigation