California Governor Gavin Newsom, a staunch Democrat, seems to want to enjoy the best of both worlds. The liberal leader was reportedly incensed after witnessing a shoplifter confidently exit a Target store with stolen merchandise, without any intervention.
Newsom narrated this incident on Wednesday during a Zoom call regarding a mental health bond measure he’s championing, as reported by The Mercury News of San Jose.
While queuing for checkout, the governor claimed to have seen a customer boldly leaving the store with unpaid items.
“As we’re checking out, the woman says, ‘Oh, he’s just walking out, he didn’t pay for that,’” Newsom recounted. “I said, ‘Why didn’t you stop him?’ She goes, ‘Oh, the governor.’”
The clerk’s obliviousness to the fact that she was speaking directly to the governor struck Newsom as ludicrous. “Swear to God, true story, on my mom’s grave,” he added.
The clerk blamed the governor’s policies for their inability to intervene in such situations. However, Newsom countered her claims by stating that California has one of America’s toughest laws regarding property theft – anything above $950 is considered a felony.
Despite his explanation and insistence on its validity (&ldash;&ldash;”it’s the 10th toughest in America. Look it up”), the clerk remained adamant about not stopping shoplifters due to state policies influenced by Newsom himself.
Upon realizing she was conversing with Governor Newsom himself, she requested a photograph with him – an offer promptly declined by Newsom who insisted on discussing this matter further with her manager.
Newsom expressed his indignation at being blamed for such a situation, questioning why he should spend $380 when others could simply walk out with unpaid merchandise.
What Newsom conveniently omitted from this conversation was the full context of the state’s laws and their enforcement.
The term “felony” is crucial here. While many states consider shoplifting a felony only if the stolen goods exceed $1000, California’s threshold is slightly lower at $950. However, the real issue lies in the lax enforcement of misdemeanor crimes (anything under $950).
Upon taking office in 2020, Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascon pledged not to prosecute a range of misdemeanor offenses, as per KABC-TV reports. This stance, coupled with liberal activist judges across the state, discourages police from arresting offenders who are likely to be released anyway.
Senate Bill 553, signed into law by Newsom last year (as reported by KSBY-TV), forbids employers from instructing employees to intercept shoplifters. This is probably what the store manager would have told Newsom had they conversed.
This results in a dual system in California – stricter laws for felony theft due to a lower threshold but negligible attention paid towards misdemeanor theft under that limit.
Criminals have caught onto this loophole and can comfortably shoplift up to $949 worth of goods without facing significant consequences – as long as they don’t cross the $950 mark.
The store could, but the majority of major retailers have a ‘hands off’ policy. Meaning, store employees are not permitted to physically stop shoplifters. Even if the police are called, they often arrive long after the thief is gone. And if the $ value is under $950, nothing else…
— TimmerMcGraw, CFI ???????????? (@TimmerMcGraw) February 1, 2024
Retailers feel helpless due to this loophole which has led to a surge in shoplifting in California despite having stricter laws for felony theft.
Critics attribute the increase in retail theft to Prop 47 – a 2014 measure that reclassified some nonviolent property crimes as misdemeanors. Yet Newsom stands by his support for this initiative, claiming it makes California’s felony theft threshold lower than Texas’, as per Mercury News.
His office also pointed out a recent CapitalOne analysis that found California’s retail theft rate to be 17 percent below the national average.
These statistics do not account for unreported crimes – such as the one Newsom witnessed at Target.
Either Governor Newsom is blissfully ignorant about how his state’s system functions or he deliberately shared this story to divert attention from the shortcomings of California’s laws.
One Twitter user commented, “It means he’s shoveling shirt to deceive by citing the felony/misdemeanor theft $ threshhold because the important distinction is that California doesn’t police theft misdemeanors the way nearly all other states do. Cali treats it as a citation like a minor traffic violation”
It means he’s shoveling shirt to deceive by citing the felony/misdemeanor theft $ threshhold because the important distinction is that California doesn’t police theft misdemeanors the way nearly all other states do. Cali treats it as a citation like a minor traffic violation
— Luke Everhart???? (@LukeEverhart1) February 1, 2024
Moments after sharing his tale, Newsom expressed hope that reporters weren’t present during his call – seemingly realizing that his narrative could make headlines.
But perhaps this was his intention all along.
